---
title: "Margaritaville Resort Times Square — New York"
description: "A four-star Margaritaville on Seventh Avenue — Times Square 0.2 km, pool listed, soundproof rooms listed — with flat 10s on service and location and inconsistent-amenity complaints at 8.72."
url: "https://travelshifu.com/hotels/new-york/margaritaville-resort-times-square/"
type: "hotel review"
source: "TravelShifu"
---

# Margaritaville Resort Times Square

A four-star Margaritaville on Seventh Avenue — Times Square 0.2 km, pool listed, soundproof rooms listed — with flat 10s on service and location and inconsistent-amenity complaints at 8.72.

## Verdict

Book it for Times Square and the pool listing; read the inconsistent-amenity and breakfast-expectation warnings before you pay upscale Midtown money — several categories sit at 8.72 beneath flat 10s elsewhere.

The address is theatre-district core: Times Square 0.2 km, Broadway 0.3 km, Rockefeller Center 0.6 km, MoMA 0.9 km. Location scores 10 out of 10; service and overall experience do too, from 6,561 reviews captured 18 December 2025.

The supplier rating is 9.2 out of 10. Cleanliness, room quality, amenities, value and food and beverage all sit at 8.72 in the property’s records — an unusual flat cluster below the 10s on service and location. Cons name small rooms and inconsistent amenities, including pool availability language in the amenities summary.

Facilities list fitness centre, swimming pool, restaurant, bar, soundproof rooms, parking and pets allowed. That pool listing matters against the Riu, but the guest analysis says some advertised amenities were not available — read that before you book for the pool.

Breakfast expectations versus price appear in the food summary without a quoted rate. JFK is 22 km on the POI row.

## Does Margaritaville Times Square have a pool?

A swimming pool is listed in the amenities we cite, but the guest analysis notes some advertised amenities were not available. Check availability for your dates on the partner — we do not guarantee the pool is open from static data alone.

## Why are some scores 10 and others 8.72?

That is what our hotel data provider returns — service, location and overall experience at 10 out of 10, while cleanliness, room quality, amenities, value and food and beverage sit at 8.72, all from 6,561 reviews as of 18 December 2025. We show both patterns plainly.

---

Canonical HTML: https://travelshifu.com/hotels/new-york/margaritaville-resort-times-square/