Courtyard if AICM and early flights are the job; Presidente if Polanco, Chapultepec and a five-star band justify the 12 km airport transfer — accepting food scores (8.09) and no pool listed.
Position is the entire comparison. Courtyard: airport 0.4 km, Zócalo 8 km. Presidente: airport 12 km, Chapultepec 0.4 km, Masaryk 0.5 km, Zócalo 5.5 km. Location scores 9.9 against 10 — both strong within their own job description.
Supplier rating favours Courtyard on the headline: 9.4 from 2,699 reviews against 9 from 1,952, captured 7 January 2026 and 6 January 2026 respectively. Service is close — 9.96 against 10 at Presidente. Courtyard leads cleanliness (9.49 against 8.6); Presidente leads on Polanco geography and star class.
Facilities: Courtyard lists airport shuttle, pets, family rooms, soundproof rooms — no pool. Presidente lists airport shuttle, pets, hot tub/Jacuzzi, restaurant — no pool listed either, with guests wishing for pool/sauna in the analysis. Courtyard is four-star midrange; Presidente is five-star IHG.
Complaints: Courtyard names breakfast and value issues; Presidente names cleanliness at check-in, food quality and small rooms. Pick the complaint you can live with for the pin you actually need.