New York hotels · head to head
Chelsea High Line against Midtown West — Flatiron at 0.2 km against Penn Station at 0.6 km — gallery walks versus Hudson Yards practicality.
By Kaiser Khan · last reviewed
Rates for both move constantly, so nothing here quotes a price. Each full review carries the rate comparison for that property.
Same four-star band, different West Side experiences. Pairing either with Times Square would muddle a Chelsea-versus-Midtown West decision readers actually face.
We publish a handful of comparisons per city, chosen by an editor. We do not generate a page for every possible pairing: at thirty hotels that would be 435 near-identical pages per city, and at five hundred it would be 124,750 for one city alone — which is a doorway-page pattern, not a service to anybody trying to pick a hotel.
Should you book this hotel?
Motto if the High Line and flat 10 category scores are the bet; Arlo if Penn Station, Hudson Yards and parking listed matter — accepting Arlo’s small-room and noise cons and Motto’s limited-space caveat beneath the 10s.
Position splits cleanly. Motto puts the High Line and Flatiron at 0.2 km and Times Square at 1.7 km; Arlo puts Penn Station at 0.6 km, Times Square at 0.7 km and Hudson Yards at 1 km. Location scores 10 against 9.73 — both strong, aimed at different maps.
Supplier ratings: 10 out of 10 from 4,105 reviews at Motto against 9.4 from 7,354 at Arlo, captured 18 December 2025. Motto’s flat 10s sit beside a limited-space highlight; Arlo’s room quality is 8.77 with size, noise and privacy cons. Arlo lists parking; Motto does not in the first twenty-five amenities cited.
Both list fitness centres, restaurants, bars, terraces and pets allowed. Neither lists a pool in the facility set we cite for Motto; Arlo has no pool in its first twenty-five either.
LGA is 12 km from Motto and 13 km from Arlo on the POI rows — effectively tied for airport geography.
Verdict last reviewed . Rates, refurbishments and management change — re-check anything time-sensitive before booking.
4-star hotelChelsea & High LineMotto
A four-star Motto by Hilton on West 24th Street — High Line 0.2 km, Flatiron 0.2 km, restaurant on site — with flat 10 out of 10 category scores and a limited-space caveat in the highlights.
Third-party guest reviews: 10.0/10 from 4,105 reviews — as of
4-star hotelMidtown West & Hudson YardsIndependent
A four-star Arlo on West 38th Street — Times Square 0.7 km, Penn Station 0.6 km, parking listed — with strong service and location scores and small-room, noise and privacy complaints.
Third-party guest reviews: 9.4/10 from 7,354 reviews — as of
Every row is checkable against the supplier data on the two property pages. “Level” is a real answer and is used — a comparison where one side wins every row is usually a comparison somebody wrote backwards from the conclusion.
| What is being compared | Motto by Hilton New York City Chelsea | Arlo Midtown | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Official classification | 4-star | 4-star | Level |
| Position | Chelsea. High Line 0.2 km, Flatiron 0.2 km, Times Square 1.7 km. | Midtown West. Penn Station 0.6 km, Times Square 0.7 km, Hudson Yards 1 km. | Level |
| Supplier rating (our hotel data provider, /10 — display only) | 10 from 4,105 reviews, as of 18 December 2025 | 9.4 from 7,354 reviews, as of 18 December 2025 | Motto by Hilton New York City Chelsea |
| Location (third-party guest score, /10 — display only) | 10 — High Line / Flatiron | 9.73 — Penn / Hudson Yards | Motto by Hilton New York City Chelsea |
| Room quality (third-party guest score, /10 — display only) | 10 — limited space still named | 8.77 — small rooms; privacy concerns | Motto by Hilton New York City Chelsea |
| Service (third-party guest score, /10 — display only) | 10 | 10 | Level |
| What guests complain about | Limited space in guest rooms (one review) | Small rooms; noise; privacy concerns | Motto by Hilton New York City Chelsea |
| Parking | Not in first 25 amenities cited | Parking listed | Arlo Midtown |
| Pets | Pets allowed | Pets allowed | Level |
| Nearest iconic anchor | High Line 0.2 km | Penn Station 0.6 km | Level |
Rows taken: Motto by Hilton New York City Chelsea 4, Arlo Midtown 1, level 5. Counting rows is not how you pick a hotel — one row usually decides it, and the verdict above says which.
Every property we cover in New York, the areas they sit in, and the verdict on which area suits which trip.
Neighbourhoods, transport, what a day costs, when to go and what to skip — the long-form guide behind these hotel picks.
